How Birchbox Uses Data to Find Online Success [Case Study]

Until recently, e-commerce had left the beauty industry in the dust.  Women need precise color matches for their makeup, and they like to smell, touch, and try products before buying them (Griffith, 2014).  Enter Birchbox’s sampling program, which brings the in-store experience to women and men’s homes.  Through this program, Birchbox has created awareness and demand for beauty brands that you would normally know nothing about.

Brief History on Birchbox

Birchbox was founded by two friends, Katia Beauchamp and Hayley Barna, who both agreed on one thing: Shopping for products was frustrating, inefficient, and confusing.  How were customers supposed to navigate the vast range of options? And in the growing online market, how could they try products without buying them all? (Birchbox, n.d.) The first shipment of Birchboxes went out in September 2010, and soon realized that men needed a better way to shop too.  Birchbox Man launched in April 2012, to bring guys tailored shipments of grooming and lifestyle products (Birchbox, n.d.).  For a new customer, you can sign-up at birchbox.com, and fill out your “beauty profile.” The cost is $10/month for the female box and $20/month, for the man’s box.  Each month Birchbox well send you a box of sample products that are curated based off your profile. 

How Birchbox Uses Web Analytics to Monitor Visitor Traffic and Customers

While Birchbox has done a phenomenal job in content and social media marketing, they have also done an excellent job with implementing and analyzing customer data and web traffic.  Web analytics is always intriguing, since it gives a tangible shape to visitor behavior and can play an important role in determining online success (Nagpal, 2013).  In the beginning, the effectiveness (or the ROI) of the content Birchbox produces depends by channel.  For their videos, it’s views.  For their blog, which is on Tumblr, it’s followers, unique views, and how many reblogs they get.  For the website, they use Google Analytics to track page-views, time on page, and bounce rate – there was a lot more they would like to do, but at the time, it was a work in progress (Snow, 2011).  Today, Birchbox has put a major emphasis on analytics with their traffic and customers, with an entire group dedicated to analyzing data.  Birchbox now employs people with job titles of brand campaign analyst, statistical analyst, and Director of analytics.      

From February 2013, Birchbox saw 111,917 monthly visitors, now compare that to February 2014 where they saw a jump to 334,357 monthly visitors.  This indicates that initial visitors are returning each month, and these visitors are also talking about the site amongst their social networks which is drawing in even more new visitors monthly (Boyd, 2014). 

Birchbox started off as only available online and was focused on tailoring a box to various complexions, hair types, and looks, but Birchbox’s utilization of data goes far beyond these physical traits.  “From the beginning, data has been an essential part of Birchbox’s growth and strategy …we use it to make important company decisions, and use it to guide us towards creating the best possible new products for our customers,” explained Deena Bahri, VP of Marketing at Birchbox (Adobe, 2013).  Birchbox has used big data when launching a new service or product offering, and for Birchbox Man they used both behavioral and survey data (Adobe, 2013).  Their surveys and behavioral data, Birchbox has continued to improve their product offerings and deliver what the customer wants and stay relevant.

Conversion rates have been another one of their main measurers of success.  For example, Stila Cosmetics sent a sample of one of their products to 7% of Birchbox subscribers based on their beauty profiles.  The product saw an 11.2% conversion rate into a full-sized purchased, a number that seems small, but in the beauty industry is strong for a SKU (Sultana, 2014). 

Tools Birchbox Uses to Stay Relevant

Birchbox takes data seriously and uses multiple tools to track that data from visitors and their Birchbox subscribers, because a “one size fits all” approach no longer works.  One of those tools is Custora, a predictive analytics platform for e-commerce marketing teams (n.d.).  Custora’s software analyzes data to predict how customers will behave in the future – the things they’re likely to buy, how much they’ll spend, even how often they’ll shop (n.d.).  For Birchbox, one of the areas of focus was driving their subscriber-base to make purchases in the Birchbox Shop, which features full-size versions of sample products, as well as additional beauty and lifestyle products hand-picked by the editorial team (n.d.).  Using Custora’s platform, Birchbox was able to discover activation strategies that increased profit per customer, by over 70%.  Additionally, Birchbox learned which types of customers do not respond to certain types of email marketing (Custora, n.d.).  According to Deena Bahri, VP of Marketing at Birchbox, “Custora  goes beyond reporting, helping to uncover true insights about our customers – then they make it easy to test and refine marketing strategies.” (Custora, n.d.).  Another tool that Birchbox uses, is Tealium, for tag management and analytics.  Tealium (n.d.) provides web analytics managers with an hourly feed of all their rich, correlated, event-level data, which can be integrated into any data warehouse or visualization solution.  Lastly, Birchbox uses Google Analytics and DoubleClick Floodlight.  Google’s DoubleClick Floodlight Counter tag allows Birchbox to count the number of times that users have visited a particular page after seeing or clicking one of their ads (n.d.).

Other tools that Birchbox uses for website tracking tools are:

• §    Advertising – AdExtent, Google AdWords, Google Dynamic Remarketing, and MediaMath
• §    Beacons – Chango, DoubleClick Floodlight, and Proclivity
• §    Social – Facebook Connect and Facebook Social Plugins

For those customers that are browsing/ shopping, but leave items in their cart, they have a way to get you back! Birchbox uses strategically timed emails for their abandoned cart nurturing (Burke, 2014).

As you can see, Birchbox uses a light-hearted approach and tells you exactly what you forgot in your cart, price included (Burke, 2014).  Within that email you have two CTAs, instantly checkout or edit your cart options.  It removes the friction and allows customers to go straight to their carts without having to navigate around the site (Burke, 2014). Birchbox follows up the next day, reiterating a sense of urgency. 

Something to note about Birchbox, the famed online retailer of cosmetics will be opening its first brick-and-mortar store in New York City.  The company has attracted more than 800,000 users since launching in 2010, but only around 30% of its revenue comes from full-product online sales from Birchbox.com (Groth, 2014).  Its new store is an attempt to figure out why that percentage isn’t higher.  Birchbox co-founder Katia Beauchamp describes the Soho store as a “laboratory.” The store is designed to reflect its online presence with iPads that showcase product reviews and a beauty bar where customers can test out different looks similar to the makeup and hairstyling tutorials on their website (Groth, 2014).  The SOHO store will use in-store analytics, by using cameras and heat sensors to track customers as they make their way around the store, seeing which products they’re attracted to and how they use the iPads (Groth, 2014).  Birchbox is also looking to add WiFi analytics and want to make the Birchbox app “a companion to the store.” When connected to WiFi, the app would be enabled to send push advertisements and collect customer data, like how many times the user has visited Birchbox and what products she’s purchased (Groth, 2014).

Another way Birchbox is gaining data, is straight from their box subscribers.  Each month, after you receive a Birchbox, subscribers can gain 10 points per item reviewed from their box.  On average, a subscriber receives 5 items for a possible 50 points.  For every 100 points, Birchbox gives you $10 off to use in their online store and can be redeemed in that year.  The product surveys are a mix of quantitative and qualitative data for the product, which helps gauge interest in the product, as well as possible purchase of the item.          

  

How Birchbox Uses the Data They Collect

With their trove of data on trends and demographics, which is used to help brands develop and launch their products, Birchbox is considering developing its own line of products (Griffith, 2014).  With their customer data, Birchbox will also be experimenting with more categories targeted at women.  The company is looking to explore project-based boxes like craft projects, cooking projects or party themes, as well as home décor and work supplies (Griffith, 2012).

Birchbox For the Future

Navigating Birchbox’s web and social presence, you can understand why they are at the top.  So what could Birchbox implement to keep moving them forward? Offering customer service chats, a large number of websites have a chat feature to interact with their visitors.  This allows them to offer real-time assistance and advice, promote a service/product to the visitor, and some chat applications offer integration with web analytics tools (Team Position 2, 2010).  It would be recommended that Birchbox install a ‘virtual pageview’ code linked to the ‘on click’ event of the “Chat Now” button.  “Virtual pagview” was suggested instead of “event tracking” as Birchbox would want to carry out a funnel analysis on the conversations (Team Position 2, 2010).  A funnel would be set up in GA, which would track clicks on the chat button – from initiating a chat conversation to signing up for monthly subscription, as one example.

Birchbox has set the bar high in the world of e-commerce.  For anyone looking to start an e-commerce business, Birchbox is a great brand to mimic in every aspect!

References

Adobe. (2013, May 6). 8 Marketers doing big data right. Retrieved from http://mashable.com/2013/05/06/cmo-data/

Birchbox. (n.d.). What is Birchbox? | Birchbox. Retrieved December 8, 2014, from https://www.birchbox.com/about/birchbox

Boyd, M. (2014, April 21). Best eCommerce websites: Birchbox skyrockets with subscription retail. Retrieved from http://ecommerceinsiders.com/ecommerce-websites-birchbox-skyrockets-subscription-retail-1798/

Burke, M. (2014, September 25). 3 Reasons people abandoned your shopping carts, and how to solve it [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://blog.klaviyo.com/2014/09/25/3-reasons-people-abandoned-your-shopping-carts-and-how-to-solve-it/

Custora. (n.d.). Birchbox & Custora: 70% Increase in repeat buyer conversion. Retrieved December 8, 2014, from https://www.custora.com/customer_results/birchbox_custora_customer_analytics_retention_marketing

Google. (2014). DoubleClick Floodlight counter tags - Tag manager help. Retrieved December 8, 2014, from https://support.google.com/tagmanager/answer/3281074?hl=en

Griffith, E. (2012, October 19). The beauty of Birchbox: it’s not subscription commerce, it’s marketing that women actually pay for. Retrieved from http://pando.com/2012/10/19/the-beauty-of-birchbox-its-not-subscription-commerce-its-marketing-that-women-actually-pay-for/

Griffith, E. (2014, April 21). Exclusive: Birchbox banks $60 million. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/2014/04/21/exclusive-birchbox-banks-60-million/

Groth, A. (2014, July 23). Birchbox is using its retail space to track customers offline. Retrieved from http://qz.com/237400/birchbox-is-using-a-retail-space-to-track-customers-offline/

Hartjen, R. (2014, July 31). Birchbox: A laboratory for shopper behavior | RetailNext [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://retailnext.net/blog/birchbox-a-laboratory-for-shopper-behavior/

Hayes, M. (2013, February 21). 32 Key performance indicators (KPIs) for ecommerce - KPI examples [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.shopify.com/blog/7365564-32-key-performance-indicators-kpis-for-ecommerce

Nagpal, M. (2013, October 25). 2013 Top ecommerce websites analytics benchmarks. Retrieved from https://vwo.com/blog/2013-top-ecommerce-websites-analytics-benchmarks/

Snow, S. (2011, August 1). How startup Birchbox uses content To sell tons of beauty supplies. Retrieved from http://contently.com/strategist/2011/08/01/how-startup-birchbox-uses-content-to-sell-tons-of-beauty-supplies/

Sultana, R. (2014, July 10). Big data series: Birchbox is all about the conversion… and its working [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://rumi03.com/2014/07/10/big-data-series-birchbox-is-all-about-the-conversion-and-its-working/

Team Position 2. (2010, September 2). Analyzing "chat quality" using Google Analytics - Funnel analysis - Position² [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://blogs.position2.com/analyzing-chat-quality-using-google-analytics-funnel-analysis

Google: Just A Data Collector or Future SkyNet?

Image Source: Wikipedia

There’s no doubt that we live in a very connected culture! With rise of social sharing sites like Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram, we can’t help but share our lives with others.  Social media has had such a profound effect on our culture that earlier this year the Oxford Dictionary added the word “selfie,” which goes to show how much we love sharing with the world.  What happens when we want to search the world?

If we are with friends and debating a topic, the next thing you hear is, “Just Google it!” In less than a second you have your results and your answer, but what really happens when you go to Google, type in your search query, and hit enter?

Under their privacy policy, Google (n.d.) says they collect information to provide better services to all of their users – from figuring out basic stuff like which language you speak, to more complex things like which ads you’ll find most useful or the people who matter most to you online.  So the question is, what exactly do they collect? According to Google (n.d.), they collect information in two ways:

1.   Information you give them.  As an example, if you sign up for a Google account and give your name, address, and then this info could be public within your Google profile. 

2.    Information Google gets from your use of their services.  Google may collect information about the services that you use and how you use them, like when you visit a website that uses their advertising services or you view and interact with their ads and content (Google, n.d.).  This can include specific phone model, log information, location information, unique application numbers, local storage, and cookies and anonymous identifiers (Google, n.d.).

Everyone has different privacy concerns, I probably tend to lean towards not being as worried compared to the average American. Where I might be concerned comes from the following statement about Google storing data on people.  According to RT USA (2014), Google’s business model is the spy.  It makes more than 80 percent of its money by collecting information about people, pooling it together, storing it, indexing it, building profiles of people to predict their interests and behavior, and then selling those profiles principally to advertisers, but also others.  Who exactly is the “others?” While none of the other items really worry me, it’s that “other” category that has me questioning how much goes to “other.”

Google on the other hand, claims their goal is to be clear about what information they are collecting, so that you can make meaningful choices about how it used (n.d.).  Google list the five following ways you can take control of your information:

·      Review and control certain types of information tied to your Google Account by using Google Dashboard.

·      View and edit your preferences about the ads shown to you on Google and across the web, such as which categories might interest you, using Ads Settings.  You can also opt out of certain Google advertising services here.

·      Use Google’s editor to see and adjust how your Google Profile appears to particular individuals.

·      Control who you share information with.

·      Take information out of many of Google’s services.

Sort of sounds like Google isn’t so bad after all, right? Well earlier this year, Google took a hit from Europe’s highest court.  The European Court of Justice has ruled that search engine operators are responsible for the processing they carry out of personal data which appear on web pages published by third parties – and that a form of contentious “right to be forgotten” already exists (Bernal, 2014).  The ruling was a strong decision in favor of privacy and individual rights, and against the business models of search engines.  Google has become one of the main ways we search for a story, so if you prevent Google from providing the link, you prevent people from accessing and reading the story.  Perhaps people in European countries are more private than those in America? Not so! Even before the European ruling, a potentially explosive lawsuit made its way through federal court.  The lawsuit states that Google had acknowledged scanning the contents of millions of email messages sent and received by student users of the company’s Apps for Education tool suite for schools (Herold, 2014).  In the suite, the Mountain View, Calif.-based company also faced accusations from plaintiffs that it went further, crossing a “creepy line” by using information gleaned from the scans to build “surreptitious” profiles of Apps for Education users that could be used for such purposes as targeted advertising (Herold, 2014).  As consumers grow more technologically savvy, you can expect more and more of these type of lawsuits to pop-up, unless Google does something sooner than later.   

We know Google already dominates search, email, digital advertising, and many other areas of digital, but what is next? Remember earlier in my post, when I mentioned the “other” category? Let me first start by saying I am all for digital, social, and others forms of communications.  I am not one of those conspiracy-type people, but just what will Google do with their acquisitions of robotics companies and artificial intelligence company, Deep Focus? I don’t ask this to scare those who are already paranoid, but I do think it’s important for Google to clearly define those purposes as these projects move closer and closer to mainstream usage.  

Aside from creepy robots, self-driving cars, and flying drones, you need to decide what your usage of Google is and will be.  Chances are high that Facebook knows way more about you, based off the pages you like and things you share.  The real question is, who is the most transparent and who cares more about giving you simple options to maintaining your own preference of privacy.  Facebook might be winning this one at the moment, with the latest change to their privacy options.  Someone like me, I can live with Google and Facebook knowing about me, what I like, and what I care about.  If this means a better Internet experience, then bring it on.

I would love to know your thoughts on your usage of Google and does giving away some of your privacy matter for the using their products? Where do you draw the line?

References

Bernal, P. (2014, May 13). Opinion: Google privacy ruling could change how we all use the Internet. Retrieved from http://edition.cnn.com/2014/05/13/business/opinion-google-privacy-bernal/

Google. (n.d.). Privacy policy – privacy & terms. Retrieved from http://www.google.com/policies/privacy/

Herold, B. (2014, March 17). Lawsuit alleges that Google has crossed a 'creepy line' with student data. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/03/17/google-data-mining-students_n_4980422.html

RT USA. (2014, October 30). Google data collection worries Americans more than NSA. Retrieved from http://rt.com/usa/200687-google-nsa-data-collection/

Free vs. Paid: Moz Analytics and Google Anayltics

Gone are the days of creating a campaign and placing a 1-page ad in the most read magazines and a 30-second commercial on one of the most watched TV shows.  With technology, a modern marketer can track pretty much anything on the web.  Analytics platforms are commonly used and allow marketers and CEOs to understand how to continuously optimize websites, content, and social outreach (Hilhorst, 2014). 

If we were creating an Internet marketing campaign and two of our strategies were creating an SEO strategy and perhaps a PPC campaign, then we would want to measure the results through an analytics tool.  Getting Internet marketing right is tricky, and it’s nearly impossible to get it all right the first time (Cummings, 2014).   Search engines like Google are constantly making changes to their algorithm, which means something that worked before, may not work this time around.  Tracking your results will help you identify what is and what is not working, and helps you improve and customize your marketing efforts to best fit your needs, and the need of your target audience (Cummings, 2014). 

This week, I needed to identify another tool in the marketplace that wasn’t Google Analytics.  First thing that came to my mind, thanks to me following their blog, was Moz.  If you aren’t familiar with Moz, they are one of the Internet’s leading search engine marketing companies, and offer a complete web analytics package (Sparks, 2014).   Their analytics can help you track your search marketing, social media marketing, brand activity, links, and content marketing efforts all in one convenient location (Sparks, 2014).  In 2008, Moz launched their own crawl (now called Mozscape) so they could provide online marketers with insights they can’t get anywhere else (Moz, n.d.).  Their most recent Mozscape Index has over 189 Billion URls (Moz, n.d.).   

For comparison purposes, we will look at the pro version of Moz Analytics.  With their tools, you can measure and improve your search, social, brand, and content marketing with Moz Analytics.  Perform in-depth research on your site – and your competitors – with their research tools (Moz, n.d.).  Moz Pro subscriber’s benefits include educational resources, answers to tough technical questions from their community of professional marketers, and more. 

·      All your data in one place - You can track the performance of all your inbound marketing efforts on one platform, then shows you the relationships between your content, SEO, social activity, brand mentions, and inbound links (Moz, n.d.) 

·      Beautiful visualizations of your data over time - Moz Analytics gives you a picture of how your efforts have performed over time. Watch the trend lines of your growth and momentum, and highlight factors that have caused shifts in performance (n.d.).

·      Competitive Analysis – Moz shows you all of your data in a comparative view with your competitors.  Scope out their link profiles, traffic, social activity, mentions of their brand online, trending content pieces, and more.

·      Actionable Insights for Your Next Steps – Moz Analytics gives you insights you can act on – and data to help you prioritize your next move.  Learn what keywords can optimize for to boost traffic, discover missing meta-tags, delete duplicate page content, and optimize your site for quick wins.

·      (Source: Moz, n.d.).

Moz Pro’s and Con’s of Moz Analytics

The biggest pro for Moz analytics is they offer some of the best tools on the market for link management and analysis.  You can really get a lot of information about how to improve your SEO campaigns (Sparks, 2014).

The biggest con for Moz analytics, they don’t actually measure your traffic.  As a result, you would need to be familiar with both Moz Analytics and Google Analytics in order to get data about your traffic patterns (Sparks, 2014).

Google Analytics and Moz Analytics

While I haven’t used Moz Analytics, I would like to offer what I see as the comparisons and differences, between Moz and Google Analytics.  Moz first started as an SEO tool, but has transformed into an analytics tool, with a focus on empowering inbound marketers.  First, it’s important to note that the Moz platform syncs with Google Analytics and pulls data on your site’s inbound channels to provide different insights than what you might be accustomed to from Google Analytics (Wallace, 2014).  The biggest difference with Moz, is the beautiful data visualization over time with custom reporting, competitive insights to help with research, and actionable recommendations to improve your performance (Wallace, 2014).  With Moz Analytics, it’s not an either Moz Analytics or Google Analytics, cause it relies heavily on Google Analytics to do its job.  While Google provides you with the data from your marketing efforts, Moz takes that data and creates data visualization graphs, along with insights that you can act on.  Under their On-Page Optimizations, they have an On-Page Grader tool that evaluates any page on your website, or even your competitor’s, and assigns a letter grade A-F. The grade is based on on-page optimizations related to a specified keyword (Wallace, 2014).

According to Wallace (2014), the report evaluates everything from title tags and keyword usage to canonicals and semantic markup.  It even displays a target keyword for that page and the recent change in rankings.  This is no doubt a tool that would come in very handy for the newer SEO pro and I would find this type of information very informative.

As someone who is very passionate about social media, Moz Analytics also offers you the ability to sync your social accounts.  This allows you to not only monitor interactions such as retweets and shares, but you can see traffic-driving retweets and shares (Wallace, 2014).  This level of detail simply isn’t available with Google Analytics.

In conclusion, Moz seems to have a very powerful tool, but it doesn’t come free like Google Analytics.  Moz will run you anywhere from $99/month, up to $599/month, a price that might not be available to businesses with small budgets.  I'm definitely intrigued by Moz Analytics, but see GA as the better choice.  With Google Analytics Academy and some invested time, GA would be also be the more fiscally sound choice too.  

Have you or do you currently use Moz Analytics, or do you mainly stick with Google Analytics? Is there another analytics tool that you find valuable?

References

Cummings, A. (2014). Top e-marketing metrics you should be monitoring [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://blog.ispionage.com/top-e-marketing-metrics-monitoring.html

Hilhorst, A. (2014, October 8). Data, design and analytics: Is this the future of marketing? [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.onalytica.com/blog/posts/data-design-and-analytics-is-this-the-future-of-marketing

Moz. (n.d.). Software for managing inbound marketing and local SEO. Retrieved from http://moz.com/products

Moz. (n.d.). Why choose Moz? We know marketing data. Retrieved from http://moz.com/products/why

Sparks, C. (2014, March 11). 10 Great social and web analytics tools. Retrieved from http://www.searchenginejournal.com/10-great-social-web-analytics-tools/90629/

Wallace, S. (2014, June 12). Moz Analytics review: How it fits into your toolset [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.neboagency.com/blog/how-moz-analytics-fits-into-your-existing-toolset/